There are some menswear essentials that are so well-loved these days, it seems a bit too good to be true, especially when you consider the full rotation of the best men’s shirts up for grabs at NYC-based Faherty Brand. The family-owned brand is more than just a menswear and women’s wear company – they believe in crafting products with good intention and great storytelling, the type of pieces you can wear day-to-day and for special occasions, and the Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt is one of those much-loved menswear essentials that seems too good to be true… but actually isn’t. It’s the perfect entry in our ongoing Style Pick of the Week series, because it checks plenty of the right boxes.

You see, the Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt is many things at once: It’s a classic flannel shirt made to layer underneath a rugged Faherty sherpa trucker jacket, but it’s also a dependable overshirt, a cozy winter shirt for weekend lounging, and the sort of stylish men’s shirt you can wear untucked with your favorite pair of chinos to the office on a more laidback day.

The Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt is plenty well-reviewed and much-loved by fans of the brand, boasting 751 reviews at an average of five stars — sure enough, Faherty reviews are quick to call out the rugged styling potential and yet ridiculously soft feel of the newly iconic, classically modern Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt. It’s the kind of shirt that looks like a throwback weekend essential, the kind your father or grandfather might have worn to get work done on cold winter days, but it’s so much more than that. The Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt is available in an astonishing 15 colors and patterns, for one, so style points are covered with one of the best men’s shirts for winter.

The Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt also has comfort in spades where it counts, using polyester, viscose and spandex to provide an astonishing amount of stretch and wearability, particularly when layered over, say, one of the best men’s henley shirts from Faherty. That’s just one of the classic combos that truly set the Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt apart from the pack, and it only gets better from there. It’s also made to be worn when comfort and warmth really count, be it on a winter weekend getaway or a casual Saturday around town — it’s designed to be layered like an overshirt or one of the best men’s shirt jackets, complete with two front-button chest pockets for your everyday carry essentials. At the end of the day, the Faherty Brand Legend Sweater Shirt just gets the job done if it’s one of the best men’s shirts for winter you want on your back. You won’t be disappointed in this one.